We chose McHale's based on the recommendation of our reception venue. We wanted traditional comfort food and McHale's delivered. Everyone was fantastic to work with, from our original representative, Courtney, her replacement, Julia, and all of the service staff, led by Phyllis. My husband says he needs a Phyllis at home all the time.... We enjoyed going to their kitchen to taste the plethora of meal options, even down to the salads. The staff was helpful with suggestions and pairings.
On the day of the wedding, the staff made sure that everyone's meals and dietary restrictions were accommodated for.
We loved that we were able to incorporate a Graeter's ice cream sundae bar into the reception and the premium bar offerings. At the end of the night, the staff made sure that we were able to eat whatever ice cream flavor we had asked be kept aside for ourselves and packaged up the remaining meals for us to decide whether to keep for ourselves or give to the band or other staff.